Skip to content

Love, Simon

“you can exhale now, Simon”

Coming off a strong year where the LGBT-community could boast in some proud releases, the 2018 season begins with more of an exhibition in learning, than a production of lasting effect. Love, Simon, a moving tender opus blue without the competence of writing or character development, weirdly manages to be so forgettable that it achieves perhaps the exact effect intended in boring the audience into accepting the normalcy of “coming out.” As David Sims (The Atlantic) notes: “[its] the kind of movie you could easily catch up with on cable TV years later and forget just as quickly—but even that’s a kind of step forward.”

A step forward indeed, but I am again (see this and this) forced to celebrate this progress in expansion of narrative diversity by impressing on the learning opportunity, having little else to celebrate. Benjamin Lee (The Guardian) gets it: “there’s an almost educational significance for a wider audience in its well-orchestrated portrayal of the specific and intricate difficulties of being a gay teen.” Sure, this is important, which is why I even hesitated to offer a review having no desire to discourage the importance of seeing the film and considering the foreign concept for most that gay teens must undergo in their fears regarding how people will react. In this sense, there is a sad comparisons in our culture today regarding the fear of coming out and the fear of reporting sexual harassment and being fired the day after.

That said, in its plagiarism of better films, Love, Simon doesn’t match any of them: in writing (Elizabeth Berger and Isaac Aptaker), falling short of the creative sharpness of Kelly Fremon Craig’s Edge of Seventeen; in music, falling short of Pretty in Pink or even Kings of Summer; or, in acting, falling way short of Lady Bird or the brilliant supporting performance by Ezra Miller in Perks of Being a Wallflower (who resembled the character played by Clark Moore, who essentially played no purpose besides being the cliché token gay). And let’s not even try comparing Logan Miller to Jon Cryer. For people unfamiliar with the great high school films, Love, Simon may feel like something special. But for the rest of us, it almost feels like growing up in the 21st century and finally seeing Woody Allen’s Bananas and being bored because the jokes have become recycled ad nauseam. Of course, don’t tell that to Brian Truitt (USA TODAY) who compares this “truly excellent” film to something reminiscent of John Hughes, instead of Degrassi.

I won’t even go into the poor casting decision of having Jennifer Gardner and Josh Duhamel together as some ploy for Christmas rom-com nostalgia, the nauseating Gossip Girl overlays, and that last scene where Gardner tries to add a poignant moment that screams of incompetent writing in comparison with James Ivory & Michael Stuhlbarg (in CMBYN) delivering a truly impactful moment of acceptance.

It really is a shame that Love, Simon couldn’t be better, especially given the significance of the film in becoming the “first studio-made, teen-targeted romantic comedy to focus on a closeted gay protagonist coming out in high school.” As Tre’Vell Anderson writes: “[t]he fact that Fox [Studios] chose to lean into the film’s identity is a step in the right direction as the industry continues diversifying its stories and the people responsible for telling them.” There will hopefully come a time when LGBT-themed films will no longer enjoy the grace period of inflated reviews based on subject matter and have to fend for themselves in creating genuinely quality works like Call Me By Your Name. Reviews like the type offered by Sheila O’Malley; whom, while  correctly noticing the significance of the single best line of the film (“[y]ou can exhale now, Simon”), have an exhausting and unseemly preference for everything (see her reviews). Same goes for Peter Debruge, who likewise trips over O’Malley in rushing to be the first to congratulate every politically correct idea despite his seeming ability to recognize how average the movie is: describing how Love, Simon is “an important first, even if the movie is pretty much average in all other respects.” Pretty much average means pretty much average, you don’t need to give it participation credit to get press invites to the next cast party for This Is Us. Or maybe you do, I wouldn’t know.

As Dan Schindel (The Film Stage) writes, while “undeniably a good thing that [Love, Simon] exists . . . I just hope that it paves the way for [something] better . . . down the line.”

RATING: C+

 

1 reply »

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

Follow us on Instagram

While the weaving of the past, present, & future was effective, #IslandSoldier lost me in the mundane unfolding of events that spoke more about the available footage, than about a creative vision that @nathanfitch aimed to display. Full review available now. #atlantafilmfestival #Micronesia #documentary #Gortnacul_at_the_Festivals
Have you caught #manhuntUnabomber yet? With over almost 90 percent accuracy this details the 16 bombings of #tedkaczynski starting in 1978. He went to #Harvard when he was 16 and is a mathematical prodigy who’s currently serving 10 life sentences without the possibility of parole. #mustwatch
Two features tomorrow at the @atlantafilmfestival, but tonight, one of my favorite director’s early films: IL DIVO. Writer-director Paolo Sorrentino received the Cannes Jury Prize for this biopic about the fabled Italian politician Giulio Andreotti (Toni Servillo).
CHALLENGE: ‪Director Milos #Forman died Friday at age 86. As one of the leading lights of the #Czech New Wave in the 1960s, he joined a #generation of #young #filmmakers that built a creative #bulwark against #communist #oppression. He was one of the very few directors whose film (One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest) won all five of the major #Oscars in one year (Film, Director, Acting, Writing). The @nytimes has an article suggesting what and where to watch 9 of his great films titled “9 Great Milos Forman Movies to Stream.” We invite you to the month of May’s #FormanChallenge, where we watch all nine films and rank them while reading his memoir: #Turnaround. Send us your list and we’ll post it online. #Movie #film #challenge #streamNOW #milosforman #watching #watchingmovies #Netflix #Amazon #Itunes #Hulu #Vudu #Fandango #filmwave #newwave
%d bloggers like this: